Can education serve as a catalyst for social progress and change?

by Professor Dr Irfan Ahmed Rind
2 mins read
education as a tool for social change

The recent murder of Dr Ajmal Sawand, an Assistant Professor at Sukkur IBA, has sparked protests against feudalism and tribal chiefs in Northern Sindh. However, the question remains: where do these tribal chiefs derive their power from, and why does this ancient system persist in the region? One of my previous studies may provide some clues to this phenomenon.

In 2017, I analyzed the results of the Standardized Achievement Test administered by Sindh government to assess education quality in public schools. Surprisingly, economically weaker regions like Tharparkar and Umarkot performed better than stronger regions like Shikarpur, Kandhkot and Ghotki — something that contradicts the popular belief that economic strength positively impacts education quality. Out of curiosity, I conducted an anthropological study to understand this phenomenon by recording the experiences of three generations living in these regions, and analyzing the data using various theories including Karl Marx’s “Conflict Theory” and Jean Lave and Etienne Wenger’s “Community of Practice”. The findings were surprising.

The first generation in Tharparkar and Umarkot perceived themselves as a “minority living among a hostile majority”, and their ultimate goal was “survival with peace and respect”. They initially believed that financial power would achieve this goal, but due to the finite resources of the desert region, most remained at the poverty line, and those who attained financial stability faced harassment from hostile groups. The realization that education was the key to securing positions of power for the community’s survival and respect led the second generation to struggle for basic quality education. They invested their time and energy in ensuring the quality of primary and secondary schools in their regions and established various support systems to facilitate educational mobility. Communities of practice were established to achieve this goal, without any designated leaders, rather anyone who succeeded in education were cherished and exemplified as leaders. These leaders maintained ties to their regions and created support systems to enable their third generation’s educational mobility and success.

On the other hand, the third generation in Kandhkot, Shikarpur and Ghotki, particularly in the Kacha area, perceived themselves as a community surrounded by hostile groups, with each community bound by tribes struggling to access finite resources. Community of practices were also established here with the tribal chief as its core to reinforce themselves by promising their tribal votes to potential MNA/MPAs in return for government jobs, contracts and police protection. All members are expected to protect the honour of the chief by voting for his selected party and the honour of the tribe by avenging any hostile action of other tribes, investing all their time and energy in conflicts. Education is seen as “useless” and for “cowards” since the educated members of the tribe usually avoid participating in conflicts, migrate from the region and have no connection with their community.

Dr Ajmal Sawand, a resident of Kandhkot, however, returned to his region to educate his people, but his people were more interested in maintaining the honour of their tribes. They killed him because he belonged to the opposite tribe, identifying him as ‘Sawand’ rather than ‘Dr Ajmal’, a PhD from France and social change agent.

This tale of resilience and rigidity highlights the power of education to break through barriers and transform lives in one region, but paints a grim picture of another. While we mourn the loss of Dr Ajmal, the stories of those who have persevered against all odds offer hope for the future. It is crucial that we continue to support education as a tool for social change and strive to produce more individuals like Dr Ajmal until they outnumber the ignorant ones.

Acknowledgement/Credit: Published in Daily Express Tribune on 4 May, 2023

Work-in-Progress

“The State of Children in Pakistan” is work in progress and the beta version has been released for testing purposes to get feedback on structure, layout and content.

Content Review and submission

We welcome and encourage you to review the content and provide feedback to help us correct errors, add useful information, provide updated information and further improve the recommendations. In addition, you are welcome to share with us articles, research, publications, case law, and other useful developments that fit the objective of the portal. Please share your feedback through feedback form 0r email us at info@stateofchildren.com.

Website Content Review

We welcome visitors to review the content of The State of Children in Pakistan website to correct, update and improve it. An editorial team will review your contribution and include it with an appropriate acknowledgement. Please use the “Submission Form” to send us your suggestions.

 

Implementation of Article 25A in Pakistan
Previous Story

Education: A moment for introspection and taking action

child marriage in south asia
Next Story

Decline in child marriages is slow

Latest from Blog

LHC directed Punjab Government to revise Child Marriage Restraint Act 1929

LAHORE: Declaring the definition of ‘child’ in the Child Marriage Act, 1929 unconstitutional, the Lahore High Court has directed the Punjab government to revise the provincial version of the legislation and end the age-based distinction between males and females. `The definition of child in the 1929 Act while making a…

Non-Muslim women vulnerable to forced conversion

ISLAMABAD: United Nations (UN) human rights experts have expressed dismay at the lack of protection for women and girls belonging to non-Muslim communities in Pakistan, saying that they remained vulnerable to forced marriages and conversions, Dawn.com reported. “Christian and Hindu girls remain particularly vulnerable to forced religious conversion, abduction, trafficking,…

Malala looks forward to working with govt to uplift education sector

ISLAMABAD: Nobel Peace Prize winner Malala Yousafzai after showing concerns over 26 million out-of-school children and a large number of vacant seats for teachers in Pakistan has offered a helping hand and asked the prime minister to focus on the education sector to promote education. Malala Yousafzai in a letter…

Govt to declare education emergency

ISLAMABAD: Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif on 9 April 2024 announced that the federal government would declare an education emergency in the country and would provide all possible resources to educate children of poor families. He vowed to replicate his idea of free education to children of the poor and deserving…

Missing minor girl found dead in Kotri

DADU: An eight-year old girl, who had gone missing since evening a day before, was found dead in a desolate place in Kotri Site area on 8 April 2024. Father of the victim, Liaqat Ali Hazara, said that his daughter had left home in Mahmood Shah Colony in Kotri Site…
Go toTop

Don't Miss

Unspoken Barriers

RECENTLY, at a history conference on academic freedom held at
Implementation of Article 25A in Pakistan

Education: A moment for introspection and taking action

On April 19, 2010, the Constitution Act also known as