Courts Must Prioritise Best Interests Of Child: SC

2 mins read

ISLAMABAD: The Supreme Court has held that as the custodians of justice, the courts must adopt a child justice approach that prioritizes the best interests of the child, recognizing their vulnerabilities, developmental needs, and potential.

A two-member bench of the apex court – comprising Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah and Justice Ayesha A Malik – dismissed a petition, challenging the verdict of Lahore High Court (LHC). “By adhering to these principles, the judiciary not only fulfils its legal obligations but also demonstrates judicial sensitivity towards children, contributing to a just and compassionate society,” says a five-page judgment, authored by Justice Syed Mansoor Ali Shah. As per the case, Malik Moazam Mahmood, the respondent child following the divorce of his parents in 2009 and subsequent death of his mother, filed a suit for maintenance through his maternal grandmother against his father Malik Mahmood Ahmed Khan (“petitioner”). The trial court decreed the suit, fixing the maintenance allowance at Rs5,000/- per month, effective from November 2009 until the respondent attained the age of majority, with a 10% annual increment, vide judgment dated 21.09.2015. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner appealed the additional district judge, Lahore, which was dismissed as non-maintainable vide order dated 17.10.2015. Subsequently, the petitioner challenged the judgment in the Lahore High Court, Lahore which was dismissed in limine vide order dated 11.05.2016 (“impugned order”). Justice Mansoor Ali Shah held that the Constitution of Pakistan, 1973, provided a robust framework for child justice. Article 25(3) empowers the state to enact special provisions for the protection of children, including measures that may favourably differentiate them from adults. Article 25A mandates free and compulsory education for children aged 5 to 16 years. “Courts, particularly at the district level, must adopt this approach to ensure that the justice system meets the unique needs, rights, and vulnerabilities of children,” the court.

It further said by prioritizing children’s best interests in judicial decisions, the judiciary could promote long-term societal benefits, reduce recidivism, and support the development and well-being of future generations. “As the saying goes, “In serving the best interests of children, we serve the best interests of all humanity,” says the judgment.

The court held that Article 35 obliged the state to protect children, while Article 37(e) ensures just and humane working conditions, explicitly prohibiting the employment of children in vocations unsuitable to their age or sex. “This constitutional framework underscores child justice, prioritizing the well-being, rehabilitation, and reintegration of children into society, while addressing their unique rights and vulnerabilities within judicial processes,” says the judgment. The court further held that as a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (“UNCRC”) in 1989, Pakistan was under an international obligation to take special measures to protect and rehabilitate children who come into conflict with the law. The court noted that the UNCRC provided a framework for child justice systems globally, emphasizing dignity, rehabilitation, and reintegration. Pakistan’s constitutional mandate, combined with its international obligations, has catalyzed the establishment of a child justice system in the country. “We have examined the present case with a child justice lens, prioritizing the best interests of the child – an approach that the courts must employ when dealing with cases involving children in contact or in conflict with the law,” says the judgment. “In this case, we see no jurisdictional error, illegality, or procedural irregularity in the impugned order; therefore, we are of the view the impugned order does not warrant any interference and leave is therefore, declined and this petition is dismissed,” the judgment concluded. The bench had heard case on Dec 19, 2024.

Opinion Published in News Daily on 28 December 2024.

Previous Story

LHC Makes Buses Mandatory For Private Schools’ Registration

Next Story

Alarming Rise Of HIV In Pakistan: 1,079 New Cases Every Month

Latest from Blog

Fee Hike For FA , FSC Exam Sparks Outrage

The Education Boards have announced a significant increase in admission fees for the upcoming annual Intermediate examinations for FA (Faculty of Arts) and FSC (Faculty of Science), scheduled to begin on April 22, 2025. This move, which affects both regular and private students, mandates the online submission of admission fees…

Punjab Has The Highest Child Mortality Rate

LAHORE. Shortage of food, poor health of mothers and a high population growth rate cause the death of 73 of every 1,000 newborn babies in Punjab before reaching the age of one year, a fact sheet released by an international non-governmental organisation (NGO) has revealed. According to experts of the…

Legislation, Awareness Urged To Combat Thalassaemia

ISLAMABAD: Minister for Housing and Works Mian Riaz Hussain Pirzada on 30th December emphasised the need for legislation, awareness, mandatory premarital lab tests and modern research to combat thalassaemia in Pakistan. During his visit to the Thalassaemia Centre of Sundas Foundation in F-9 Park, he inaugurated an activity room established…

With 149 Outbreaks In Sindh, Deadly Measles Makes A Comeback

• Health dept data shows 132 children died from vaccine-preventable disease this year • Expert laments parents not utilising free vaccines against 12 major diseases KARACHI: Measles — a highly contagious but vaccine-preventable viral infection — is rearing its ugly head again after affecting thousands of children and killing at…
polio

Polio Tally Climbs To 68 On CUSP Of New Year

ISLAMABAD: The country reported yet another case of wild poliovirus (WPV1) on 30th December, bringing the total number of cases this year to 68. The Regional Reference Laboratory for Polio Erad­i­c­a­tion at the National Ins­titute of Health confirmed that the case was detected in Dera Ismail Khan. “This is the 10th…
Go toTop