Sindh High Court Rejects Bail Plea of Man in Minor Daughter’s Rape Case

2 mins read

KARACHI: The Sindh High Court has dismissed a bail application of an accused in a case pertaining to rape of his minor daughter.

A single-judge bench of the SHC headed by Justice Omar Sial observed that around 10-year-old victim had appeared at the trial, narrated the ordeal and her testimony carried an air of authenticity and did not appear to be tutored or coached in any manner.

The applicant has been charged with allegedly raping his underage daughter at their house within the remit of the Aziz Bhatti police station in December last year.

After the dismissal of his post-arrest bail application at the trial court, the accused through his lawyer moved the SHC and after hearing both sides as well as examining the record, the SHC turned down his bail plea.

The lawyer for the applicant, Sanam Mustafa, took the plea of false implication and when queried as to the motive behind such an accusation, she asserted that it was the third marriage of the complainant, the victim’s mother, with the accused.

The counsel argued that at the time of the marriage, the accused had agreed to gift the complainant a plot while the applicant’s daughter from his first wife would be married off to the complainant’s nephew, but after the marriage disputes arose and the woman had expressed a desire to reconcile with her first husband.

She further contended that the false accusation arose from this matrimonial discord while the medical evidence on record was inconsistent and did not support the accusation.

An additional prosecutor general of Sindh opposed the plea and supported the decision of the trial court.

The bench in its order noted that the arguments advanced by the counsel for the applicant were not only insensitive, but also served to trivialise the trauma endured by the survivor.

It also said, “Further, the contents of the bail memo reflected a dismissive and condescending attitude toward women who choose to remarry, reducing a deeply personal decision to a point of criticism. Such remarks and insinuations are deeply troubling and not appropriate from a legal professional — more so given that the counsel herself is a woman, from whom a greater degree of empathy and awareness on issues affecting women could reasonably have been expected.”

The bench further observed that the victim has appeared as a witness at trial and narrated the ordeal to which she was subjected by her father and upon tentative assessment, her testimony carried an air of authenticity and did not appear to be tutored or coached in any manner.

The victim’s post-incident behaviour and conduct, as described in her testimony, also appears natural and consistent with that of a child who has experienced trauma, it added.

It noted that the delay in lodging the FIR at this stage did not materially benefit the accused in the given circumstances of the case. Furthermore, the victim had absolutely no motive or mala fide intent to falsely implicate her own father at the behest of her mother.

The bench also said the girl was medically examined on Jan 1, and a medical report indicated that accusation may well be substantiated while samples were collected for DNA analysis, but the laboratory did not detect presence of spermatozoa and the reasons for the same have been duly noted in the report.

“It is further relevant that the definition of rape under the Pakistan Penal Code has been significantly expanded, and now encompasses a range of acts that do not necessarily require penetration. In view of the foregoing, the bail application is hereby dismissed,” it concluded.

Published in Dawn, June 21st, 2026.

Previous Story

Three Minor Girls Drown in Jhelum as Mother Attempts Suicide

Next Story

Pakistan Child Labour Surveys Evidence For Action

Latest from Blog

Two Teenage Girls Move Court against Child Marriage Law

PESHAWAR: Two teenage child rights activists on Nov 7 moved the Peshawar High Court, seeking to bring Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s child marriage law in line with those of other parts of the country by increasing the minimum permissible marriageable age for girls from 16 to 18 years. In a joint petition,…

Experts Call for Making Fire Safety Education Part of School Curriculum

KARACHI: City planners, fire safety experts, emergency responders, disaster management authorities and rescue officials on Thursday stressed the urgent need to introduce fire safety education as a subject in school curriculum, warning that a lack of awareness about disaster preparedness and management could further compound the suffering caused by such…

CCD Kills Man Accused of Killing Mother, Two Sisters

LAHORE: The Crime Control Department (CCD) on Nov 5 killed in an alleged encounter a suspect accused of murdering his mother and two sisters in the name of honour in Multan. Aman Abbas was killed in Kahror Pacca after he allegedly escaped from the CCD custody on Wednesday night, according…

Charsadda Girls School Building Declared Unsafe

CHARSADDA: The education authorities here have ordered the immediate closure and sealing of 14 classrooms, an office, a hall and a science laboratory at Government Girls Community Model High School in Charsadda after a technical inspection declared the building unsafe. According to an official memorandum issued by the district education…

12-year-old Boy from Balochistan Dies of Rabies in Karachi Hospital

KARACHI: A 12-year-old boy from Balochistan, who had been battling rabies for the past four days at the Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre (JPMC), died at the facility on the evening of Nov 4. Sources said that the patient with a history of dog bite developed rabies despite getting the vaccine…
Go toTop