FCC Rules Child Marriages Punishable but Not Void Under Law

1 min read

ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court has ruled that while underage marriages may invite criminal liability under the Child Marriage Act, 1929, such unions cannot be declared void, holding that the law provides only for penal consequences and does not invalidate the marriage itself.

In a detailed judgment authored by Justice Hassan Azhar Rizvi, the court also held that under Islamic law, a Muslim man is permitted to marry women from the “People of the Book”, including Christians and Jews.

The ruling came in a case involving a Lahore-based girl, Maria Bibi, who had converted to Islam and married a Muslim man, Shehryar. The court declared both her conversion and marriage valid, observing that she had embraced Islam before the nikah and had submitted a formal declaration to that effect.

Explaining the legal framework, the court noted that the Child Marriage Act, 1929 — a colonial-era law still in force in parts of Pakistan — criminalises marriages where either party is below the prescribed age, but does not render such marriages void or voidable. Instead, it prescribes punishments, including fines and imprisonment, for those facilitating or contracting child marriages.

The court further ruled that questions relating to the girl’s age or the authenticity of religious documents, such as those issued by a Darul Ifta, could not be examined in habeas corpus proceedings, which are limited to determining unlawful detention.

It also made significant constitutional observations, declaring that the Federal Constitutional Court — not the Supreme Court — is the final forum for constitutional interpretation. It held that all courts, including the Supreme Court, are bound by its rulings, and that it is not obligated to follow precedents set by the apex court if they are inconsistent with the Constitution or statutory law.

Addressing the facts of the case, the court pointed to contradictions in the father’s claims regarding his daughter’s age. In the FIR, he stated she was between 13 and 14 years old, while during arguments, he claimed she was 12 years and nine months old.

The court also questioned the reliability of documentary evidence presented, noting that according to NADRA records, the age difference between Maria and her younger sister was less than eight months — a discrepancy that cast doubt on the veracity of the documents.

Importantly, the court emphasised that the girl had appeared before a magistrate and stated unequivocally that she had married of her own free will and without any coercion.

Maria’s father had registered a kidnapping case in July 2015, alleging that she had been abducted. However, the case was later dismissed after the girl testified that she had not been kidnapped but had married voluntarily.

Subsequently, the father filed multiple petitions claiming that his daughter was underage and was being unlawfully detained, but these were dismissed at all judicial forums, culminating in the Constitutional Court’s ruling upholding the marriage and conversion.

News Published in Express Tribune on March 26th, 2026.

Previous Story

Medics Warn Against Screen Overuse Among Children

Next Story

Pindi Records Surge in Dog Bites

Latest from Blog

Two Teenage Girls Move Court against Child Marriage Law

PESHAWAR: Two teenage child rights activists on Nov 7 moved the Peshawar High Court, seeking to bring Khyber Pakhtunkhwa’s child marriage law in line with those of other parts of the country by increasing the minimum permissible marriageable age for girls from 16 to 18 years. In a joint petition,…

Experts Call for Making Fire Safety Education Part of School Curriculum

KARACHI: City planners, fire safety experts, emergency responders, disaster management authorities and rescue officials on Thursday stressed the urgent need to introduce fire safety education as a subject in school curriculum, warning that a lack of awareness about disaster preparedness and management could further compound the suffering caused by such…

CCD Kills Man Accused of Killing Mother, Two Sisters

LAHORE: The Crime Control Department (CCD) on Nov 5 killed in an alleged encounter a suspect accused of murdering his mother and two sisters in the name of honour in Multan. Aman Abbas was killed in Kahror Pacca after he allegedly escaped from the CCD custody on Wednesday night, according…

Charsadda Girls School Building Declared Unsafe

CHARSADDA: The education authorities here have ordered the immediate closure and sealing of 14 classrooms, an office, a hall and a science laboratory at Government Girls Community Model High School in Charsadda after a technical inspection declared the building unsafe. According to an official memorandum issued by the district education…

12-year-old Boy from Balochistan Dies of Rabies in Karachi Hospital

KARACHI: A 12-year-old boy from Balochistan, who had been battling rabies for the past four days at the Jinnah Postgraduate Medical Centre (JPMC), died at the facility on the evening of Nov 4. Sources said that the patient with a history of dog bite developed rabies despite getting the vaccine…
Go toTop