IHC Rejects Accused’s Plea in Sana Yousaf Murder Case

1 min read

ISLAMABAD: The Islamabad High Court has dismissed a petition challenging the recording of a witness statement in the absence of the accused and his counsel in the murder case of TikToker Sana Yousaf.

In a detailed nine-page judgment, Justice Khadim Hussain Soomro rejected the plea filed by accused Umar Hayat against the trial court proceedings, observing that no legal flaw, irregularity or jurisdictional defect had been found in the impugned order.

The court noted that the accused had attended the proceedings through a video link, which constitutes legally valid presence. It further held that court order sheets are recognised as correct and authentic unless proven otherwise. Emphasising the importance of expeditious justice, the high court observed that trial courts are under a legal obligation to conduct day-to-day hearings to ensure early disposal of cases.

The right to a fair and speedy trial under Article 10A of the Constitution, the judgment stated, is not only a right of the accused but also serves the larger public interest.

The court remarked that it is the responsibility of counsel to remain available for the progress of the case rather than prioritising personal convenience. It cautioned against levelling allegations regarding the conduct of a judicial officer on the basis of mere apprehensions, adding that the concept of impartiality is intrinsic to judicial proceedings.

While dismissing the petition, the court observed that in case of further delay, the accused may be provided legal representation at state expense. It also directed that counsel should refrain from making unsubstantiated allegations against the trial court in future.

The petitioner had sought exclusion and re-recording of witness statements on the ground that they were recorded in the absence of the accused and his lawyer. The high court, however, found no merit in the contention and upheld the trial court’s proceedings.

Published in Dawn, March 1st, 2026.

Previous Story

Man Held Over Forced Child Marriage

Next Story

Climate Change Disrupted Academic Year

Latest from Blog

Hidden Gender Gap in School Leadership

There are significant disparities in women’s representation in leadership positions within Pakistan’s public school education system, reflecting pronounced gender inequalities across provinces. According to the Provincial Annual School Census 2023–24, the representation of female teachers in principal and vice-principal positions remains extremely low. In Punjab, for instance, less than 1%…

Unchecked Abuse

Abuse of domestic workers in Pakistan persists largely because those subjected to it have few means of seeking protection or justice. Poverty compels thousands of families to send their children into domestic employment, often without any assurance of their safety or wellbeing. Within private households, these children remain entirely dependent…

Population Emergency

Pakistan’s population crisis has reached a point where economic growth can no longer compensate for the relentless increase in pressure on limited resources. The National Population Council has recognised that rapid population growth has become a national emergency. The 2023 census recorded a population of 241.5 million, growing annually at…

Masks in Schools made Mandatory

LAHORE: The Lahore District Education Authority (DEA) has made masks mandatory for students in schools as smog persists across the city. The authority directed the government and private school administrations to ensure that students wore masks and enforce the standard operating procedures for smog prevention. The DEA chief executive officer…

Classroom Predators

The rising incidence of sexual violence in Pakistan is symptomatic of a society where impunity and institutional negligence continue to endanger women and children. That the perpetrators are sometimes individuals entrusted with the protection and education of young people makes the situation even more disturbing. The alleged rape of a…
Go toTop