Policy Framework
Federal Sexual Violence Response Framework, 2023
The Federal Sexual Violence Response Framework, 2023 provides a four-year, federal-level strategy for Pakistan to prevent and respond to sexual violence. It mandates a coordinated response system encompassing primary prevention and secondary/tertiary interventions, ensuring the state fulfills its obligation to survivors. The framework prioritizes survivor support, access to justice, and protection of rights, outlining collaborative guidelines for government agencies, law enforcement, healthcare providers, and civil society organizations.
A core component of the framework is the enhancement of response mechanisms, emphasizing survivor-centered approaches that guarantee dignity and respect. It promotes accessible reporting, medical and psychological services, and legal aid. Furthermore, it focuses on strengthening the criminal justice system by improving the capacity of law enforcement, prosecutors, and the judiciary through training, specialized units, and dedicated courts, aiming to expedite the investigation and prosecution of sexual violence cases.
Legal Framework
National Level
Constitution of Pakistan, 1973
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Pakistan, the supreme law of Pakistan, highlights the sense of equality amongst all citizens irrespective of their age, gender, ethnicity etc, declaring each citizen entitled to equal protection under law as per Article 25. More importantly, Article 25(3) puts special emphasis on the need for protection in regards to women and children, to shield their dignity and innocence from heinous crimes such as Sexual Abuse.
The Constitution recognizes the inviolability of life, liberty, and dignity of a person as fundamental rights. The specific function of the right to dignity under Article 14(1) can be identified in the right that children have their physical, mental, emotional and sexual integrity be safeguarded and maintained. Failing to do so is a violation of dignity because it stunts a child’s potential for growth and diminishes their chances to freely develop their personality, which is one of the accepted definitions of dignity. Furthermore, Article 37 prohibits prostitution as well as the publication, display and circulation of obscene literature and advertisements which may be used as a means to coerce and manipulate innocent women and children to be engaged in sexual activity.
Pakistan Penal Code, 1860
The Pakistan Penal Code, 1860 (PPC) is the main criminal code of Pakistan. There are several provisions in the PPC that are relevant to CSV such as Section 292A, 354, 354A, 355, 365B, 366A, 366B, 367A, 371A, 371B, 375, 375A, 376, 377, 377A, 377B, 496A, 509.
|
The Anti-Rape (Investigation & Trial) Act, 2021
The Anti-rape (Investigation and Trial) Act, 2021 addresses rape and sexual abuse crimes against women and children. Section 2(b) and 2(k) define the subjects of the Act as women and children under 18, regardless of gender, in cases involving offenses listed in Schedule II, specifically referencing sections of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) 1860 and the Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA) 2016. Section 3(1) mandates the Federal Government to establish Special Courts nationwide, while Section 4(1) requires local authorities to create anti-rape crisis cells and ensure public hospitals have adequate medical facilities. Section 4(2) assigns the administration of these cells to the concerned commissioner or deputy commissioner.
Section 5 outlines the duties of the Anti-Rape Crisis Cell, requiring immediate action upon receiving information about a Scheduled offense, including medico-legal examinations, evidence collection, forensic analysis, FIR registration, and other necessary acts. Section 5(3) compels police stations to inform the cell upon receiving such information, and Section 5(4) directs the Ministry of Law and Justice to issue guidelines for victim aid. Section 6(1) obligates the Legal Aid and Justice Authority to provide legal assistance to victims of Scheduled offenses, with funds specifically reserved for this purpose. Section 6(2) mandates the Special Committee to consult with the Ministry of Human Rights to form a panel of advocates and volunteers for pro bono legal assistance. Section 7 assigns the Ministry of Law and Justice the responsibility of designating a Prosecutor General and Special Prosecutors for Scheduled offense cases.
Section 8(1) establishes a Victim and Witness Protection System with guidelines for implementation, including security arrangements, identity concealment, remote testimony, relocation, financial assistance, compensation, and safe houses. Section 8(2) emphasizes timely execution and adherence to the Witness Protection, Security and Benefit Act, 2017 if rules are impeded. Section 9 details investigation procedures, with Section 9(1) requiring female police officers for Schedule I offenses and Section 9(2) establishing a Special Joint Investigation Team (JIT) for Schedule II offenses, which must include at least one female member. Section 9(4) mandates the JIT to submit reports to the Special Court through the Prosecutor General or Special Prosecutors, and Section 10 allows investigations to include related non-scheduled offenses. Section 11 focuses on victim well-being during trials, advising the Anti-Rape Crisis Cell to appoint Independent Support Advisers. Section 11(4) specifies that advisors can be doctors, psychologists, healthcare workers, social workers, or lawyers. Section 12 mandates in-camera trials to protect victims and witnesses, prohibiting publication or broadcasting of trial documentation without court approval, and Section 13 declares dehumanizing evidence inadmissible.
Criminal Procedure Code, 1898
The Criminal Procedure Code (CPC), 1898 establishes the legal framework for the investigation, prosecution, and trial of criminal offenses in Pakistan. The Code outlines the procedures that must be adhered to in order to ensure a fair and just criminal justice system. It protects the rights of the accused, ensures proper evidence collection, and promotes transparency in the legal process, serving as a comprehensive guide for the administration of criminal justice in Pakistan. There are several provisions in the Code which are relevant to this study.
|
Qanoon-e-Shahadat, 1984
Qanoon-e-Shahadat, or Evidence Law, is an important legal framework in the context of child sexual abuse in Pakistan. It helps establish rules and procedures for presenting and evaluating evidence in court. In cases of CSA&E, the law plays a crucial role in ensuring that the evidence is gathered, preserved, and presented in a fair and just manner in court. It helps protect the rights of the child victims and ensures that their testimony is given due consideration. Qanoon-e-Shahadat aims to promote justice and accountability by providing guidelines for the admissibility and weight of evidence, which is vital in seeking justice for child victims of sexual abuse.
Under Section 59, the investigating officer may solicit the help of technical experts for professional evidence in fingerprints, handwriting, chemicals, explosives, medicines and others. Expert opinions can be valuable in cases that require specialized knowledge or technical expertise, such as forensic analysis or medical examinations related to child sexual abuse. This provision ensures that the court takes into account the qualifications and credibility of the expert to make informed decisions.
The Protection against Harassment of Women at Workplace, 2010
The Protection against Harassment of Women at the Workplace, 2010, recognizes the fundamental rights of women and prohibits harassment; both physical and verbal, establishes mechanisms for reporting and addressing such incidents, and ensures the implementation of effective grievance procedures at the Workplace.
Section 2(f) broadly defines “Employee” to include anyone working under a contract, whether formal or informal, for remuneration or not, encompassing various work arrangements like regular, contractual, freelance, and even trainees or domestic workers. Section 2(g) elaborates on “Employer,” covering not just traditional employers but also heirs, successors, managers, government authorities, contractors, online business owners, and even households employing home-based workers, thus casting a wide net to ensure accountability.
Furthermore, the Act defines “harassment” in Section 2(h) as encompassing unwelcome sexual advances, discriminatory behavior based on gender, and any conduct that creates a hostile work environment. Finally, Section 2(n) defines “workplace” expansively, extending beyond traditional offices to include any location where services are rendered, including educational institutions, performance venues, and even online spaces, as well as any situation linked to work outside the office, ensuring comprehensive coverage for legal protections.
The Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act, 2016
The Prevention of Electronic Crimes Act (PECA), 2016 is a legislation that primarily aims to address and prevent electronic crimes nationwide. The main objective of the Act is to combat various forms of cybercrime, including unauthorized access to computer systems, electronic fraud, cyber bullying, and online harassment.
|
The Prevention of Trafficking in Persons Act, 2018
The Prevention of Trafficking in Persons Act, (PTPA) 2018 is a legislation regarding human trafficking crimes that is regulated nationwide in Pakistan. The Act primarily aims to prevent and combat trafficking in persons, especially with regard to women and children; to promote and facilitate national and international co-operation in the matter; and to protect the trafficking victims.
Section 2(a) defines a child as any individual under 18, regardless of gender, making them a subject under this Act. Section 3 criminalizes forced labor and sexual trafficking. Section 3(1) states that obtaining, abducting, or attempting to obtain or abduct a child or woman with the intent of forced labor or commercial sexual exploitation, using coercion, intimidation, or force, is punishable by up to seven years imprisonment, a fine of up to one million rupees, or both. Section 3(2) increases penalties when the offense is against a child or woman, leading to imprisonment of up to ten years, with a minimum of two years, and a fine of up to one million rupees, or both.
Section 4 outlines aggravated offenses, prescribing up to fourteen years imprisonment (minimum three years) and a fine of up to two million rupees for cases involving (a) grievous bodily harm, life-threatening illness, or death, (b) organized criminal group activity, (c) confiscation or destruction of travel documents, and (d) repeated offenses. Section 7 simplifies court proceedings for child victims by exempting the prosecution from proving force, fraud, coercion, or consent. Section 8(1) and (2) assigns investigation responsibilities to the police and the Federal Investigation Authority (FIA) for cases involving interstate transport of victims. Section 11(1) and (2) mandates federal and provincial governments to provide protection to victims and witnesses, prioritizing their safety by measures like relocating or limiting the disclosure of personal information.
Zainab Alert, Response, and Recovery Act, 2020
The Zainab Alert, Response, and Recovery Act, 2020 pertains to missing children and child sexual abuse, and establishes a rapid response system for immediate reporting. Section 3 mandates the federal government to form the Zainab Alert, Response, and Recovery Agency (ZARRA), which, as per Section 5, facilitates quick notification to mobilize law enforcement, media, and the public for locating and recovering missing children. This prompt dissemination of information and collaboration among stakeholders enhances the effectiveness of search and recovery operations, increasing the likelihood of safe return.
Furthermore, Section 7 emphasizes coordination between ZARRA and local police stations, requiring information sharing within two hours of a complaint and fostering collaboration in investigations and rehabilitation. Section 8 obligates police officers to comply with Section 154 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CPC), 1898, concerning missing or abducted children. Non-compliance by public officers, as stipulated in Section 182 of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC), 1860, results in imprisonment, a fine, or both.
The National Commission for Human Rights Act, 2012
The National Commission for Human Rights Act, 2012 establishes the National Commission for Human Rights (NCHR) as an independent and autonomous body responsible for the protection and promotion of human rights in the country.
Section 9 of the Act empowers the Commission to investigate human rights violations, acquires sou moto powers, can inquire into complaints and take appropriate action to protect and uphold human rights. Moreover, the Commission monitors the implementation of Pakistan’s international human rights obligations and makes recommendations for policy improvements. The Commission has a national jurisdiction, including Punjab.
The National Commission on the Rights of Child Act, 2017
The National Commission on the Rights of Child Act, 2017 is an important legislation in Pakistan that aims to protect and promote the rights of children. It establishes the National Commission on the Rights of Child (NCRC), as an autonomous body mandated to promote and protect the rights of children in Pakistan. The Commission has provincial representation as a full-time member, and the Chief Protection and Welfare Bureau also serves as an ex-officio member of the Commission.
Section 15 empowers the Commission to investigate cases of child rights violations and abuses, examine policies and laws, investigate violations of children’s rights, conduct research and raise awareness about children’s rights. Moreover, Section 17 provides that the Commission plays a vital role in shaping as well as evolving the current domestic legislation to eradicate any contemporary issues by handing out a publication of an annual report and submitting it before the Majlis-e-Shoora (Parliament) on the situation of child rights in the country.
Provincial Level
Province |
Legislation combating CSV | Reference to Law |
Explanation |
Punjab | Punjab Destitute Neglected Children Act, 2004 | Section 3(k), Section 3(k)(v) | A “destitute and neglected child” suffers deprivation of basic necessities and/or is at risk of exploitation through exposure to immoral or explicit acts. This includes both actual deprivation and foreseeable risk of such exploitation. |
Section 5 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection and Welfare Bureau. | ||
Section 16 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Unit. | ||
Section 20 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Institutions. | ||
Section 22 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Court. | ||
Punjab Marriage Restraint (Amendment) Act, 2015 | Section 4 | Criminalizes unions involving minors; a male under 18 years of age or a female under 16 years of age, by imposing penalties of up to six months imprisonment and a fifty thousand rupee fine on the adult party. | |
Section 5 | Similar punishment for those who perform, conduct, or direct an offense, barring reasonable belief of preventing it. | ||
Section 6 | Holds parents or guardians liable for promoting or failing to prevent child marriage, with penalties mirroring those for the marriage itself, except women offenders are exempt from imprisonment. | ||
Punjab Protection of Women Against Violence Act, 2016 | Section 2(r) | Defines “violence” as any offense against an individual’s physical autonomy, encompassing acts like domestic, sexual, psychological, and economic abuse, as well as stalking and cybercrimes | |
Section 4 | Mandates the government to establish Violence Against Women Centres (VAWC) and shelters for survivor support. | ||
Section 5 | Mandates District Women Protection Committees for district-level case monitoring and women’s welfare oversight. | ||
Section 6 | Establishes Women Protection Officers as essential for enforcing protection orders and providing support, thus driving the Act’s practical application. | ||
Section 7-9 | Outlines court-issued orders for domestic violence survivors: protection orders, residence orders, and monetary orders, covering restraining, housing, and financial support. | ||
Sindh | Sindh Child Protection Authority (Amendment) Act, 2021 | Section 2(c) | A “child in need of special protection measures” encompasses any child subjected to violence, abuse, exploitation, forced labor, trafficking, drug misuse, armed conflict, lack of care, HIV/AIDS, or who is missing or kidnapped. |
Section 3 | Mandates the government to establish the Sindh Child Protection Authority. | ||
Section 16 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Unit. | ||
Section 20D | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Court. | ||
Sindh Child Marriage Restraint Act, 2013 | Section 3 | Criminalizes adult male perpetrators, aged 18 or above, who contract marriage with a female minor under the age of 18, by imposing penalties of imprisonment for 2-3 years and a fine. | |
Section 4 | Similar punishment for those who perform, conduct, or direct an offense, barring reasonable belief of preventing it. | ||
Section 5 | Holds parents or guardians liable for promoting or failing to prevent child marriage, with penalties mirroring those for the marriage itself. | ||
Domestic Violence (Prevention and Protection) Act, 2013 | Section 5 | Defines “domestic violence” as encompassing gender-based and other forms of physical or psychological abuse, specifically including sexual abuse under s.5(i), perpetrated against minors or other vulnerable persons within a domestic relationship. | |
Section 11-12 | Outlines court-issued orders for domestic violence survivors: protection orders, residence orders, and monetary orders, covering restraining, housing, and financial support. | ||
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa | Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Child Protection and Welfare Act, 2010 | Section 2(e) | Defines a “child at risk” as a child needing protection, encompassing those facing various vulnerabilities like poverty, abuse, exploitation, or lack of parental care. This includes children in specific circumstances such as homelessness, involvement in illegal activities, or those abandoned or orphaned. |
Section 3 | Mandates the government to establish the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Child Protection and Welfare Commission. | ||
Section 9 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Unit. | ||
Section 12 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Institutions. | ||
Section 15 | Mandates the government to establish the Child Protection Court. | ||
Section 20 | Empowers Child Protection Officers to rescue at-risk children, below 18 years of age, requiring court presentation within 24 hours, except when the child is with a parent/guardian, in which case a court report is initially mandated, and unless the child is begging or an alleged victim of parental/guardian abuse. | ||
Section 44 | Criminalizes non-parental caregivers who willfully harm, neglect, or expose a child to suffering, including physical assault, inadequate care, or psychological abuse, face up to three years imprisonment and a fine of up to fifty thousand rupees. | ||
Section 50 | Criminalizes the seduction of a child for sexual activity or exposure to explicit material, with penalties of up to ten years imprisonment and a two million rupee fine. This includes both completed acts and attempts. | ||
Section 53 | Penalizes sexual abuse offenses, ranging from two to ten years imprisonment, or life imprisonment, and a fine up to five million rupees | ||
Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929 | Section 4 | Criminalizes adult male perpetrators, aged 18 or above, who contract marriage with a female minor under the age of 16, by imposing penalties of imprisonment for 1 month and/or a fine. | |
Section 5 | Similar punishment for those who perform, conduct, or direct an offense, barring reasonable belief of preventing it. | ||
Section 6 | Holds parents or guardians liable for promoting or failing to prevent child marriage, with penalties mirroring those for the marriage itself, except women offenders are exempt from imprisonment. | ||
Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Domestic Violence (Prevention and Protection) Act, 2021 | Section 2(p) | Defines “violence” broadly, encompassing physical, psychological, emotional, and economic abuse, explicitly including sexual abuse. This definition extends to related offenses like assault, harassment, and criminal intimidation, all inclusive of sexual abuse. | |
Section 4 | Mandates the government to establish a District Protection Committee in each district. | ||
Section 14-15 | Outlines court-issued orders for domestic violence survivors: protection orders, residence orders, and monetary orders, covering restraining, housing, and financial support. | ||
Balochistan | Balochistan Child Protection Act, 2016 | Section 5 | Defines a child in need of protection as one experiencing or at serious risk of physical, mental, or sexual violence, neglect, maltreatment, or exploitation while under the care of a parent, guardian, or caregiver. |
Section 6 | Mandates the government to establish a Child Protection Commission. | ||
Section 11 | Mandates the government to establish a District Child Protection Unit in each district. | ||
Child Marriage Restraint Act, 1929 | Section 4 | Criminalizes adult male perpetrators, aged 18 or above, who contract marriage with a female minor under the age of 16, by imposing penalties of imprisonment for 1 month and/or a fine. | |
Section 5 | Similar punishment for those who perform, conduct, or direct an offense, barring reasonable belief of preventing it. | ||
Section 6 | Holds parents or guardians liable for promoting or failing to prevent child marriage, with penalties mirroring those for the marriage itself, except women offenders are exempt from imprisonment. | ||
Balochistan Domestic Violence (Prevention and Protection) Act, 2014 | Section 4(l) | Defines domestic violence broadly, encompassing intentional physical or psychological abuse, including sexual abuse, against vulnerable persons within a domestic relationship. | |
Section 8-10 | Outlines court-issued orders for domestic violence survivors: protection orders, residence orders, and monetary orders, covering restraining, housing, and financial support. | ||
Section 14 | Mandates the government to establish a District Protection Committee in every tehsil. |
Acknowledgement: Sidra Haya Ali-Qazalbash, Policy and Legal Advisor at Obun2.